Browsers: it comes down to UI

My personal machine is a Macbook. I do almost all my web browsing on this machine. I thought it might be interesting to list off my pros/cons for each browser.

Firefox: + plugins (particularly for web dev) – slow startup time, sometimes the initial browser window gets stuck on the other monitor and I have to reset my profile which is a pain. UI feels slow, browsing is fine. Keychain (system for stored passwords) integration is poor, I have to use a plugin to get it at all and even then it doesn’t work well.

Google Chrome: + fast startup, great UI points (download UI is nice, esp. click to ‘open when finished’), best ‘private browsing’ implementation. Tabs open near the source tab, which is a fantastic optimisation. Keychain works. – recent versions have been quite unstable, I think this is something to do with Flash. Enough sites still need flash that I care about this, so I’ve switched.

Safari: + stable, has the best ‘mac’ integration of all. Popup windows going to ‘full screen’ work properly on the second monitor (different res to other monitor), only browser that manages this. – Download UI sucks. Tabbing UI lacklustre, excess tabs vanish off the side and have to be found via a clunky menu.

What’s the point? Well, I’m not choosing a browser based upon the quality of web rendering; all of them are so good that I can’t tell the difference. It’s more about the UI, and about stability. Google Chrome is the browser I’d like to use, if it weren’t for this problem with Flash; the whole browser just freezes for seconds at a time, which got too frustrating to deal with.

I wonder why browser makers have managed to reach parity in terms of render quality, javascript speed, … but not in terms of UI? Firefox is definitely the worst of the three I’ve reviewed, it feels slow and clunky and takes an age to start up. I love some of the Firefox plugins and would like to have that flexibility and functionality. I suspect that if Chrome and Safari catch up in this area, I’ll have very little reason to look at Firefox at all.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Browsers: it comes down to UI

  1. Frenchie says:

    Have you tried updating flash? I’ve not noticed any serious issues with flash in a long time although I used to have what you describe in more than just Chrome.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s